Understanding How Easements Affect Property Values in Illinois

An easement gives someone the right to use part of your property for a specific purpose - even though they do not own it. Utility companies run power lines across backyards. Neighbors share driveways. The city maintains a drainage channel along a property line. These are all easements, and they are more common than most property owners realize.

The question that comes up most often - especially when someone is buying, selling, or developing property - is whether an easement helps or hurts the property's value. The short answer is that it depends on the type of easement, where it sits on the property, and how much it limits what the owner can do with the land. In our experience, the difference between an easement that has no practical effect on value and one that kills a deal often comes down to the specific terms of the easement document and where the easement falls on the lot.

What an Easement Is and How It Affects Property Rights

An easement is a legal right to use another person's property for a defined purpose. It does not transfer ownership. The property owner still holds title to the land, but their ability to use the burdened area may be restricted. Illinois recognizes several types of easements - express, implied, prescriptive, and easements by necessity - each created under different circumstances and carrying different implications for property value. For a deeper look at how easement documents can go wrong, see our post on how poorly drafted easements create legal problems in Illinois.

The key distinction for purposes of property value is between easements that burden a property (the servient estate, where someone else has the right to use your land) and easements that benefit a property (the dominant estate, where you have the right to use someone else's land). Easements that burden your property tend to reduce value. Easements that benefit your property can increase it.

When Easements Reduce Property Value

Not all easements affect value the same way, but certain types consistently create problems for property owners.

Easements That Restrict Buildable Area

If a utility easement runs through the middle of a lot, the owner may not be able to build a structure, plant trees, or install permanent improvements in that area. For residential lots, this can reduce usable yard space. For commercial or development properties, it can make a project financially unworkable if the easement limits the building footprint or requires setbacks beyond what zoning already requires. Lenders may also view properties with significant easements as higher-risk investments, which can affect financing terms.

Easements That Affect Access or Privacy

A shared driveway easement means another party has a legal right to drive across your property. A pedestrian or trail easement may bring foot traffic through what would otherwise be a private area. Buyers tend to discount properties where they cannot fully control who enters and how. In our experience, shared driveway easements are among the most common sources of neighbor disputes and buyer hesitation in the Chicago suburbs.

Easements That Create Maintenance Obligations

If the easement requires the property owner to maintain a road, drainage structure, or shared utility, the ongoing cost becomes a factor in the property's value. And if someone is injured on the easement area, questions about liability can become complicated - particularly when the easement document does not clearly allocate responsibility.

Conservation Easements

Conservation easements permanently restrict development on the burdened property. While they serve important environmental purposes and can provide tax benefits, they typically reduce the market value of the encumbered land significantly because future owners cannot develop, subdivide, or change the use of the restricted area. The impact depends on what restrictions are imposed and how much of the property is affected.

Swipe to see full table

When Easements Have Minimal or Positive Impact

Standard utility easements along property edges are so common that most buyers do not think twice about them. As long as the easement does not interfere with the property's primary use or any planned improvements, it is unlikely to affect the sale price. In many neighborhoods, every property has the same utility easements, which normalizes the condition and eliminates any competitive disadvantage.

Access easements that benefit the property - meaning the property owner has the right to cross someone else's land - can increase value by ensuring legal access to a road, waterfront, or shared amenity that would not otherwise be available. A landlocked parcel with no access easement is worth significantly less than the same parcel with a recorded easement guaranteeing road access.

The visibility and location of the easement matter as much as the type. A utility easement along the rear property line that does not interfere with any planned use may have little or no impact on value. The same type of easement cutting diagonally across a buildable lot is a different story entirely.

How Appraisers and Lenders Evaluate Easements

When a property with an easement is appraised, the appraiser evaluates how the easement affects the usability and marketability of the property. Key factors include the size of the easement relative to the total lot, whether it restricts the buildable area, whether it affects access or privacy, and whether comparable sales in the area have similar easements.

If the easement significantly limits what the owner can do with the property, the appraiser may adjust the value downward. Lenders pay close attention to this analysis. A property with a major easement that restricts development potential may face stricter underwriting requirements or higher interest rates because the lender views the collateral as less marketable.

Title insurance companies also evaluate easements carefully. If an easement creates ambiguity about what the owner can and cannot do with the property, the title company may add exceptions to the policy - meaning the buyer would not be covered if the easement leads to a dispute down the road.

What Buyers and Sellers Should Watch For

If you are buying property in Illinois, the title search should reveal any recorded easements. But not all easements show up in the public record - implied and prescriptive easements may exist without any documentation. A thorough review of the property's history, a physical inspection, and a conversation with a real estate attorney who handles easement issues can help identify problems before closing.

If you are selling, undisclosed easements can become a problem after closing. The Illinois Residential Real Property Disclosure Act (765 ILCS 77) requires sellers to disclose known material defects, which includes easements and encroachments that affect the property. Failure to disclose a known easement can expose the seller to post-closing claims from the buyer, including claims for misrepresentation or rescission of the sale. For more on post-closing disputes, see our post on whether a buyer can sue a seller after closing in Illinois.

Negotiating Easement Terms to Protect Property Value

If you are negotiating a new easement - whether you are granting one or receiving one - the specific terms matter far more than most property owners realize. A well-drafted easement that limits the burden on the property preserves value. A vague easement with undefined scope can create problems for decades.

Key terms to negotiate include the precise location and width of the easement area, the specific permitted uses (and prohibited uses), which party is responsible for maintenance and repair, insurance and liability allocation, whether the easement can be relocated if the property is developed, and whether the easement includes a termination provision or sunset clause.

An easement that gives the holder broad, undefined rights across your property is very different from one that is narrowly tailored to a specific purpose in a specific location. When we draft or review easements for clients, the goal is always to ensure the easement accomplishes its purpose while minimizing the impact on the property's usability and long-term value.

For more information on easement disputes, property line disputes, or title issues in Illinois, visit our Real Estate Litigation practice area page.